ReviewsMovies

Revolution is Messy in Siân Heder’s Disability Advocacy Film ‘Being Heumann’

Early in Siân Heder’s Being Heumann, Judy Heumann (Ruth Madeley) rolls her wheelchair into the middle of a New York City street during a protest. Traffic stops. People stare. Other disability demonstrators follow. Sometimes getting people to acknowledge that you exist requires becoming hard to ignore.

That spirit drives Being Heumann, Heder’s dramatization of the disability-rights movement in the 1970s, and the fight to implement Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. It follows Judy’s journey from New York to San Francisco as activists demand that the federal government finally enforce protections prohibiting discrimination against disabled people. The value of the narrative is that disabled people are truly at the center of their own story. Being Heumann stars Ruth Madeley, Madeline Delp, Mark Ruffalo, and Dylan O’Brien. 

In Being Heumann, Judy Heumann is in a wheelchair, glasses, wearing a blue coat. She is smiling.
Apple Original

Not just one disability either. Wheelchair users, the Deaf, blind people, and people with different physical and developmental disabilities occupy the screen together, arguing, organizing, getting annoyed with one another, falling apart, and figuring things out as they go. The movie is particularly good when it shows how completely inaccessible everyday life was because nobody in power bothered considering disabled people in the first place. Judy was denied access to school as a child because she was considered a “fire hazard.” The same logic followed her when she wanted to become a teacher.

What Judy accomplished was monumental. She led a several weeks long demonstration and sit-in at a federal building in San Francisco, to get politician Joseph Califano (Ruffalo), who was in charge of health, education, and welfare, to sign the 504 Rehab act, all while local newscaster Evan White (O’Brien), documented the event. Protesters need medication, interpreters, accessible bathrooms, food, and basic accommodations simply to remain inside. They literally have to break things apart and improvise solutions. The irony writes itself. These people are occupying a federal building because society refuses to accommodate them, and then the building itself refuses to accommodate them.

Ruth Madeley is fantastic. She gives Judy the charisma necessary to understand why people follow her while refusing to turn her into a saint. Judy becomes militant, controlling, and at times an asshole. She is so accustomed to fighting people who refuse to listen that eventually she stops noticing when she is no longer listening herself. That is some of the film’s most interesting material.

The ensemble is excellent. Possibly some of the strongest ensemble work I have seen in some time. However, they ultimately exist to support Judy’s journey rather than having meaningful interior lives of their own. The rest of the cast bring enormous personality to roles that frequently make you wish the screenplay would wander away from its protagonist for a while. Even Mark Ruffalo’s Joseph Califano mostly represents the bureaucratic wall activists must overcome rather than a particularly complicated human antagonist.

Like Heder’s CODA, the film is extremely accessible emotionally, sometimes to its detriment. Everything is laid out cleanly. Here is the injustice. Here is the speech. Here is the triumph. Cue the inspirational music. The actual politics were messier than that.

In Being Heumann, this image is a close up of Judy huemann hands raised to the sky in protest in NYC.
Apple Original

The Black Panthers support the protesters with food and other resources. Disability activists consciously borrow organizing strategies from the Civil Rights Movement. Different disability communities have their own prejudices and blind spots toward one another. These are fascinating tensions, yet Heder mostly brushes against them instead of digging in. Most glaringly, Black women and other women of color never receive the kind of narrative space that might complicate Judy’s position as a white woman leading a movement built through interracial coalition. That absence becomes harder to ignore precisely because the movie keeps emphasizing solidarity.

Solidarity with whom and under what conditions?!

At over two hours, the movie also feels long. There are only so many stirring speeches, strategy meetings, setbacks, and inspirational breakthroughs you can stack before the rhythm starts repeating itself. That does not erase what works. Being Heumann understands something essential about disability rights in that accessibility is not charity. Disabled people should not have to inspire somebody, beg somebody, or occupy a damn federal building just to participate in public life.

The movie celebrates the people willing to force that realization onto America, and it’s still an immensely important story. I just wish it had been as interested in the complicated politics of the movement as it is in making us cheer for it.

Being Heumann is available to stream on Apple TV.


Discover more from The Nerds of Color

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Valerie Complex

Writer, Critic, and passionate about comics, movies and equality on the big screen.

Leave a Reply