The Hierarchy of Power in the DC Universe is Always Changing
Last Monday, Hollywood was rocked by the shocking news of James Gunn and Peter Safranโs ousters as heads of DC Studios. Everyone was shocked by the announcement. Everyone except long suffering fans of DC films. For those of us who have been here from the beginning, itโs more like โbeen there, done that.โ
For as long as there have been blockbuster movies featuring DC superheroes, there have been corporate shakeups, director firings, and scrapped plans. Going all the way back to the first superhero blockbuster, 1978โs Superman: The Movie, there were stories of studio executives butting heads with the director, Richard Donner. The disagreements were so severe, the Salkinds who executive produced the films, ultimately removed Donner from the sequel, even though most of the film was already shot.
Richard Lester, was then brought on to rewrite and reshoot the film and received sole director credit. It was more than two decades later before Warner Bros. released Donnerโs original vision. It also proved to not be the last time fans would demand a directorโs original vision of a film be released to the public. But more on that later.
A decade later, DCโs next crack at blockbuster superhero cinema came in the form of Tim Burtonโs game changing phenomenon, Batman. As Batmania swept across the globe, the bean counters at Warner Bros. were eagerly anticipating how Burton would follow-up the merchandising sales juggernaut that was Batman โ89. The sequel they got, the edgier and kinkier Batman Returns, didnโt sell enough Happy Meals and Burton was subsequently removed from the franchise.
Enter Joel Schumacher. In 1995, Batman Forever was a gigantic hit and brought the franchise back to life. Though brighter and campier than Returns — though, Iโd argue just as kinky — the original cut of Forever was still too dark for the suits at WB, forcing the Lost Boys director to make the movie more โtoyetic.โ That was also the mandate for the even campier sequel Batman & Robin that essentially tanked the franchise for another decade. An online movement to โrelease the Schumacher cutโ has never been officially acknowledged by the studio; however, in 2023, filmmaker Kevin Smith raved about his copy of it and even screened it for a select few at his Smodcastle Cinemas location in Jersey.
When Christopher Nolan took over the franchise in 2005 with Batman Begins, the phrase โcinematic universeโ still wasnโt a thing. Also, comic book movies did not earn a billion dollars. That all changed in 2008. While The Dark Knight won the box office war, making history as the first comic book movie to cross the billion-dollar milestone, a little upstart studio called Marvel released a film that same summer: Iron Man and a Samuel L. Jackson cameo that changed the industry forever.
It can be argued that Nolan is the only filmmaker Warner Bros. has ever allowed to fulfill his vision for their DC characters, walking away after completing the trilogy with The Dark Knight Rises. But the executives and audiences were craving interconnected superhero stories now. Though the Nolan-produced, Zack Snyder-directed Man of Steel was never really intended to launch a cinematic universe, its timing — releasing a year after Avengers made crossovers the ahem endgame going forward — meant DC had to accelerate their pace if they were ever going to catch up. So why not inject a little Batman into their Superman sequel? Iโve long argued that the smarter move would have been to invite Christian Bale back as Batman — Rises was the immediate predecessor to Man of Steel, after all. Instead, they decided to reboot (again) and cast Ben Affleck in the role in 2016โs Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Thus, the Snyderverse, nee DCEU, was born.
This period of DC Films was tumultuous, to say the least. First of all, prior to BvS, there wasnโt even a dedicated film division. But like everything else in the history of DC cinema, the formation of DC Films and the corporate shakeup was a direct reaction to the filmโs less than stellar reception. Unlike Marvel Studios, DC FIlms was not its own entity but rather a subdivision of Warner Bros. Pictures. It was co-led by WB executive vice president, Jon Berg, and the chief creative officer of DC Comics, Geoff Johns. Their tenure at the head of DC Films had some financial successes, but it was mostly associated with executives emboldened to interfere with the DC movies they had in production, namely David Ayerโs Suicide Squad and Snyderโs Justice League team-up.
While we have yet to see Ayerโs original vision for his supervillain teamup movie, the โSnyder Cutโ became cause cรฉlรจbre among the directorโs most loyal fans and finally saw the light of day in 2021 on HBO Max.
Despite the critical and commercial success of 2017โs Wonder Woman, the theatrical version of Justice League was one of the biggest financial disappointments of that year. Thus, Berg and Johns were out, and Walter Hamada came in to lead the division the following year. Hamadaโs tenure was marked by massive financial hits for the DCEU — the billion-dollar grossing Aquaman — as well as well regarded standalone movies that existed outside the shared cinematic universe — like Matt Reevesโ The Batman, not to mention the movies that could do both — like the standalone and billion dollar grosser, Joker.
Of course, Hamada had to navigate other things while leading DC Films, such as angry Snyder fans, a pandemic, and the sale of Warner Bros. to Discovery. It was in this transition that saw the most upheaval for DC Films. When Discovery CEO David Zaslav took over WB, one of his first decisions was to shelve the nearly completed production of Batgril for a tax write-off. That decision soured the relationship between Hamada and the incoming administration so much that he almost left the company. Instead, the uber producer decided to stay with the company until they released Black Adam in late 2022.
Starring Dwayne Johnson in the role he had spent nearly two decades trying to produce, Black Adam proved to be the craziest chapter in DCโs long history of crazy.
As Hamada was negotiating his exit from DC Films, Johnson and his producing partners were secretly plotting with WB Pictures chiefs Pamela Abdy and Michael de Luca to bring back Henry Cavill in the role of Superman and plan the next course of DC movies. They even filmed a post-credit scene and allowed Cavill to officially announce his return on social media. Of course, while this was happening, Zaslav was busy hiring James Gunn and Peter Safran to form DC Studios, which leads us to what happened last week.
Gunn and Safran were brought on to lead the next ten years of DC movies. Before that, though, they were stuck promoting the remaining films that had yet to release. Though Gunn infamously proclaimed The Flash was one of the best comic book films ever made, the movie was a commercial disaster — even if I kind of liked it. The last remnants of the DCEU went out with a whimper, primarily because fans knew Gunn was about to blow up the whole thing and start anew. Why should they waste their time with movies that wouldnโt lead anywhere?
When Gunn rolled out the initial โGods and Monstersโ slate a few months after taking the job, the internet was pretty much in agreement that DC was finally able to proclaim itself the direct competition to Marvelโs stranglehold on superhero cinema. Gunn promised no movie would be greenlit without a script and that everything across film, television, and animation would build toward a unified story.
His Superman in 2025 was a modest success financially, but a hit a homerun with its casting. David Corenswet, Nicholas Hoult, and Rachel Brosnahan were instant fan favorites, and though it wasnโt part of the initial slate, its sequel Man of Tomorrow was fast tracked into production. Itโs still supposed to come out next summer, but the uncertainty that surrounds the future of DC Studios is an echo of the last 50 years of DC movies.
Which brings us to last week. David Ellison and Skydance, who now control Warner Bros. after buying Paramount earlier this year, have folded DC Studios back into the larger corporate structure, pushing out Gunn and Safran in favor of Jeremy Latcham, a longtime Marvel executive who worked on everything from the first Iron Man through Guardians of the Galaxy. Latcham now reports up through Skydanceโs own film leadership rather than running DC as its own independent company, which undoes the entire structure Gunn and Safran were brought in to build in the first place. Whether Man of Tomorrow survives intact, whether Gunn gets to finish the trilogy he had planned, and whether David Corenswet, Aaron Pierre, and the rest of the current cast stick around is still very much an open question.
Very few creatives have been allowed to thrive in the DC playground, though many have made their mark despite constant studio and corporate shenanigans. What the future of DC on film will be is unknown, but weโve come out on the other side before, we can do it again. Just with a different Batman. Again.
Believe it or not, I have even more to say about this DC shakeup! Thatโs why I brought in critic, artist, and fellow DC fan Julian Lytle to talk more about the fallout of James Gunnโs ouster from DC Studios.
Discover more from The Nerds of Color
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
